Jump to content
DCW Forum

Chekhov MacGuffin

Moderators
  • Posts

    2150
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    212

Everything posted by Chekhov MacGuffin

  1. Either way, it makes sense. Probably a reference to Iron Chef's Chairman. Your translation looks correct. It's this guy. I think you are on the right track with the history reference. I forgot who Shuukichi Haneda (羽田 秀吉) was named after, but wasn't it a general or something like that? 太閤; 大閤 【たいこう】 (n) (hon) (esp. refers to Toyotomi Hideyoshi) (See 関白・かんぱく) taiko; title for a regent, later for the grand chancellor, also for the father of an Imperial adviser (advisor) who passed the role to his son
  2. So the boss is allowing the best killers in the Organization to try to murder her beloved spouse and possibly her daughter, because she is hoping her unreliable favorite will stop it in time by acting out of line? That's a pretty big error. It also goes against what Vermouth said about the boss being overly cautious. Why would the boss be so reckless with the ones she loves? The boss didn't know that Conan or Akai would be there, so they don't count. That leaves the questionably reliable Vermouth. The boss is not omniscient. Gin isn't known for lying. I can't think of a single instance where something Gin said has been proven untrue, ignoring things where Gin may have been lied to himself. The boss could say Kogoro is being mined for information, or is under watch because of involvement in past cases. Both of those are believable. Gin let Kogoro go when Vermouth lied and said she was using Kogoro for some purpose. If he listens to Vermouth, whom he does not trust after the Haunted Ship incident, surely the person that Gin works for is more trustworthy. Or, if Gin is insubordinate, have him killed. This is purely hypothetical so it can't be used as valid evidence. There is no evidence that Eri planned to force Kogoro or Ran out of the house on such short notice.
  3. Disappointed with recent case. Gosho turned Jodie into Yamamura for crappy, half-baked plot development. At least the murder mystery was decent.

  4. Jodie was extremely out of character stupid in this case. While she was never Conan or Akai level, Gosho basically made her into an idiot to force the plot forward in an extremely awkward way. Jodie was never this bad in the Vermouth or Kir arc. I'm not impressed with the plot right now. Just had to get that off my chest. I can tolerate slow plot and plot without much action as long it is plausible and the logic works, but this is character sacrifice for badly done plot progression. Jodie is a half decent law enforcement type character who even Vermouth respected for being persistent and smart enough to piece together her whacked up aging. It sucks to see her degraded to Yamamura level.
  5. Gin received permission from boss to kill Kogoro in FBI vs. Org. The boss could have easily refused, claiming Kogoro is part of a plan or something. Gin is pretty loyal. Also, Eri did not know Ran went over to Agasa's. She could have been killed as well. Don't you think the boss would think it is risky to rely on Vermouth to defy Gin rather than take the simple route and tell Gin to stand down for now? Also Midori is an anime original character who appeared late in the manga as a cameo. Gosho would not have written her into the main plot without setting her up as a serious character in the manga first. Ditto goes with the movie 2 plot. It has to be in the manga to be considered canon.
  6. Seems like an appropriate thread to note that Knightus mentioned that DCTP's regular weekly chapter translation might be ending sometime soon. No official announcements but in his words: "I'll be honest - after over 250 chapters, I think the group may have finally reached the point where weekly translation is no longer sustainable. Sorry if this news causes a panic. In the future, I imagine, we probably won't be able to do every single case. But, anyways, we're not announcing anything yet... might have more info in May (when the anime operation ends)."
  7. What the banana guy said. Translating looser means you don't have to spend time making everything semantically perfect. In one piece, it really won't make a difference to the overall plot whether Sanji got locked in a cabinet or a dresser and used "one-inch-kick" or a "super close range knee" to escape. (Blatantly made that up if you can't tell.) If it was Detective Conan, you might have to know the victim damaged his right big toe while attempting to break the hinges of the heavy pine dresser facing the kitchen. That's pretty much true. The translating team isn't that big, and most of the people working are adults with full-time university or jobs which cuts back on the free time quite a bit. Luckily they keep up better when something important is going on..
  8. I have similar thinking to Rye except I think Vermouth may have been one of the original members - which means she is at least as old as the Black Organization. (See my theory for Vermouth being Sharon Vineyard's mother if you want to know more about that). Rather than being experimented on by Org scientists, I think there was an accident or something like that that stopped her aging, but the formula was lost. The Org has been trying to replicate it since, and that is why the Miyano's were brought in thirty years ago. Vermouth didn't like being a research subject/the ideals of the Org, so she came to hate the Miyanos.
  9. She seems to be suspecting because Moroboshi Dai (the name she knew Akai as) and Okiya say similar things. She tried to take off Okiya's scarf presumably to see what was underneath (Voice changer? Scar? Tattoo? Unique jewelery? there are lots of theories). However, after the train case she demanded Conan tell her know who he was, but Conan only replied with he is an ally. Maybe she is guessing Okiya is Dai, but she isn't sure. Amuro seems to know Conan is the puppet master behind sleeping Kogoro, but it isn't clear that he knows Conan is Shinichi. No one has talked about Shinichi in front of him yet. He definitely doesn't know Haibara is Sherry. I am guessing that he doesn't know either identity yet, although he may figure out Shinichi's soon. I don't think there is more to Calvados' death. Copy pasta from DCTP: The pocket pistol Calvados used was small, so it would be easy to miss. I don't think the Org has undercover agents in the FBI. Remember they didn't know Kir was in a hospital until Vermouth questioned the child and even then they didn't know which one until they sent out agents. A spy in the FBI should be able to feed them that info. (Unless the spy was in a completely different branch of the FBI that had no idea what the Japan branch is doing - which would be pretty useless.) Same goes for which van Rena was in. At the strategy meeting, all the FBI learned Camel was going to drive the van with Rena but Gin still had to deduce which one was the right van. Lastly, Conan spoke in front of all the FBI during the strategy meeting, yet nothing bad seems to have happened to Conan later.
  10. Tried watching Movie 6 again. I failed within the first 10 minutes. The man trying to break into Hiroki's room was blocked by a small chair. Keys, do you know how to use them?

    1. Kyuu Nye

      Kyuu Nye

      Come now Chek... you know that is a common movie trope. Still doesn't make it any less ridiculous though, I grant you.

    2. Balthazar Manfredie

      Balthazar Manfredie

      i kinda feel that M6 is overrated

      still its better then most new ones that came out

  11. Any way you look at it, you pretty much were translating like you had your arse on fire. If you are a single person who is translating and writing it down, a normal rate would be 1-2 chapters a week for someone with normal time commitments, more if you are very fluent, and less if you are busy. If you are typesetting too, 1 chapter a week or less would be normal for a single person's work. If you are cleaning, translating, and typesetting as a single person, 1 chapter every two+ weeks seems like a decent pace. This is why people form teams to make fan translations of weekly manga. You need 3+ people on board to keep up. Those crazy guys who release a chapter of popular manga in a few hours literally have a mini-team for every one or two pages. Some manga have more writing and more difficult terms than others. Bleach will go faster than Kindaichi. All above mentioned rates should be adjusted for that. DC is one of the harder mangas to translate because it is text heavy and full of technical terms. Also you have to be really precise for DC because mysteries depend on it; You can be looser with something like One Piece.
  12. I could be wrong, but I thought the scene of the shadowman jumping through the window was original animation and not from an episode.
  13. That's damn good time. I'm impressed. 500 pages = 31 sixteen page chapters That's 2/3rds of a full chapter a day.
  14. "Gold coins to a cat" is nearly identical to the English phrase "throwing pearls before swine". A cat has no interest in gold coins, so throwing gold coins to a cat is a futile action or a waste of resources.
  15. Found out someone copied text from DC Wikia today. Even if it is allowed, please don't do it! It makes us look like badguys.

    1. Show previous comments  1 more
    2. Balthazar Manfredie

      Balthazar Manfredie

      as long as you give credit to where credit should be given to me its OK

    3. Chekhov MacGuffin

      Chekhov MacGuffin

      Technically the licensing means we can borrow from a wiki or wikia if we cite where we got it from. Copying from Wikipedia is okay if we cite back. The problem in this case is the text is from DC Wikia, our competitor so to speak. Taking it from them feels like poor form.

    4. Lovestruck

      Lovestruck

      Loving the sound of competition ^

  16. The administrator of the DC wikia alerted us to the fact that our articles on Gosho Aoyama and the Gosho Aoyama Manga Factory contain sections copied verbatim from their wikia. While this is technically allowed because of the way wiki licenses work, it's annoying on principle because it makes us look bad and unoriginal. I would really appreciate anyone with time taking a look at those articles and helping us rewrite them to to make them pure Detective Conan World work. Thanks and any help is appreciated.
  17. Just to let you know, we have a thread on this topic already. Be sure to check the thread reference guide before making a new topic to see if it already exists. http://www.detectiveconanworld.com/forum/topic/4288-how-detective-conan-will-end/
  18. I am not sure what you are trying to say. Spamming people is bad. Please don't message 50 random people to read your fanfic. That said, if 15 people commented on someone's last fanfic thread, and that writer wanted to tell those 15 people there is a new fic they posted at a fanfiction site, that is probably okay. In general, the moderators don't go around looking for things that might be problems (except for things that could get the site sued or are disruptive). People report problems to us, and then we take action. If someone spams people fanfiction ads and you report to us you have been spammed, we'll take a look. Otherwise we assumed that you were okay with being told about a fanfiction.
  19. Thanks for troubleshooting all this. There seems to be a really nasty issue going on with linking.

  20. There seems to be some bizarre things going on with the links after the switch to the new forum. I tried to edit the first post and some things appeared to have been deleted. If you recall something that has been deleted, please let me know.
  21. Second call, but has anyone who hasn't already notified me have very large popup ads appear when they visit the site? If so can you tell me what pages and how often you see them?

  22. Maurice wanted to know if if the large popup ads only appear on just the wiki, or just the forum, or the whole site. And on mobile mainly or desktop as well?

  23. Maurice wanted to know if if the large popup ads only appear on just the wiki, or just the forum, or the whole site. And on mobile mainly or desktop as well?

    1. Ren-kun

      Ren-kun

      Sorry for the very late response but I've encountered it on the forum and while I'm on the PC.

  24. Has anyone besides The Banana Exorcist seen large popup ads on DCW like this: http://sta.sh/01oc7itfp2q2

    1. Show previous comments  2 more
    2. Ren-kun

      Ren-kun

      Same as Amontillado.

    3. Lovestruck

      Lovestruck

      Hmm, I use my iPhone to get to DCW. So, in my situation I get ads popped when I access to DCW. Then, when I try to get back to DCW, I couldn't. So I had to close the window and open another one. :/

    4. Erza Scarlet

      Erza Scarlet

      I just saw one like that today! it doesn't bother me as much tho.

  25. I doubt giant popup ads are supposed to appear. Maybe something slipped through the advertising partner? Still sounds sketchy. I'll ask about it.

×
×
  • Create New...