ugh, this is why i hate when he does wordplay *face palm* i feel better though, i thought it was my deduction, but the wordplay is impossible for me to solve, those puns just don't make sense to me. I agree there wasn't enough info because how would you be sure the rat did it? How do you prove it, and how do you explain the books? I was wondering why the colors were associated with each animal.*sigh* at least a sniper is involved :grin: Go abs!