Idk if there is sth wrong with my taste or not. For eg, Psycho Pass is a popular one but really it did not give me any strong feeling, only some serious thinking and to me it is not enough. And for Fullmetal Alchemist, I READ MANGA while my friend watched anime. She said she cried a lot and others too but I didn't...But at least I finished those 2, unlike Tokyo Ghoul... Gave up really soon.
Maybe you can ask Akazora since he's quite into reviewing animes (cuz I'm too lazy to review it for u sr )