Jump to content
Detective Conan World

Balthazar Manfredie

Renowned
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Content Count

    8505

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    35

Posts posted by Balthazar Manfredie

  1. Posted · Report reply

    6 minutes ago, DCUniverseAficionado said:

     

    So was Mystery Train a B or a C, then? And what about Red Shirts?

     

    Well, she's known for nearly 200 files/over 5 years, and hasn't made a move. If she's going to try again, what's going to be different in her third attempt at doing so? If nothing else, this has been a period where the BO no longer considers Shiho/Ai a threat to their secrecy. Shiho/Ai has always been either a part of the BO's system, or was sought after by all of them—this is the first time that neither one of these is true.

    i gave at that time the train case an 8/10

    what grade that is you can tell me, since i dont know

    as for the red shirts

    i thought

    how could any BO case after the  clash even live up 

    red shirts was a nice continuation to it if you will

    like a end to and end, if that makes sense 

     

    im saying that she will hunt her but it wont make anything different

    Ai is going nowhere

  2. Posted · Report reply

    6 hours ago, DCUniverseAficionado said:

     

    So, for instance, while Black Impact and Clash of Red and Black felt like Team Shinichi/Conan Vs the BO, Mystery Train and Scarlet Showdown just felt like Team Shinichi/Conan Vs Bourbon (a NOC) and Vermouth (a disloyal member, when it comes to Shinichi/Conan and Ran)? And then there's the length and repetition.

     

    Though I will say that Mystery Train created the new status quo of the BO thinking Shiho/Sherry is dead—upsetting the old status quo that had been a thing for over 600 files/just under 15 years—and that new status quo has held steady for nearly 200 files/over 5 years.

    I think  BO cases  started to go downhill from there 

    my favorite cases are the ones that take place on a train, with the addition of the BO you would think i would have a blast

    it was good, bit my expectations were so high that it didnt meet them

    while red T-shirts case was surprisingly better then i thought it would be ( when i broke it down )

     

    but doest Vermouth know she is alive

    and if she knows, to me it makes no difference 

    she will hunt her

  3. Posted · Report reply

    6 hours ago, DCUniverseAficionado said:

     

    Think nothing of it. ^_^ It can be pretty quiet on here—compared to DCTP, at least.

     

     

    And it didn't narrowly win out 1st place—it won by a wide margin.

     

    Seems they have different priorities and interests—they really seem to be into Shuichi and Rei/Toru/Bourbon, Heiji and Kazuha, and Shinichi and Ran. And they seem to want DC to keep on going, where many on here think that the fact that it's gone on this long is only to DC's detriment.

     

    They put Moonlight Sonata on there, as well as the Matsuda Serial Bomber case, the Mermaid case, Golden Apple and Desperate Revival. They seem to value those particular classics, at least.

     

     

    What are your grades for the other arcs (including the Rum arc, so far)?

    i would love it if their priorities changed 

    however i do think those oldies e are great cases

     

    well

    ill go with this ( including anime too)

    i think that from start till up until the end of vermouth arc things were looking great, minor AO problems

    things after that started to loose steam

    while Kirs arc was good without the AOs, but having them there really ruined it for me

    i still like it but its less to enjoy

    and then bourbon started off nicely but became a drag and the reveals were so meh, the AOs were bad

    its the same for RUM but just a bit better then bourbon, also the AOs were bad

    now its just recycled plots for everyone with a few things polished

     

    everything till Vermouth A

    cell phone B

    ill give Kirr without the AOs A with them B-

    Bourbon D

    Rum C

  4. Posted · Report reply

    9 hours ago, DCUniverseAficionado said:

     

    On here? Sure. In Japan? Here's a pretty recent Shonen Sunday poll about the best DC cases (https://www.facebook.com/DCTheRedThread/posts/1549149298470351):

     

    1. Scarlet Return - Vol.85 File 894-898 (8489 votes)
    2. Mermaid's Curse - Vol.28 File 279-283 (5835 votes)
    3. Moonlight Sonata - Vol.07 File 62-67 (5742 votes)
    4. Holmes' Book of Revelation (London Arc) - Vol.71-72 File 743-752 
    5. Trembling Metropolitan Police HQ - Vol.36-37 File 369-373
    6. Memories of the Sakura gumi (Shinichi and Ran's first meeting case) - Vol.87 - File 921-924
    7. Ebisu bridge - Vol.83 - File 879-881
    8. Golden Apple (Kudo Shinichi's NY case) - Vol.34+35 - File 350-354
    9. Mystery Train - Vol.78 - File 818-824
    10. Desperate Revival - Vol.26 - File 252-257

     

    If so, then for the 2007–present period, more than anything else. I guess it depends on just what grade you give the Bourbon arc (whether you give it a C or an F).

    i know everyone has their opinion and i respect that

    but i just cant see how scarlet return ended up being first

    no red vs black

    no 20 year old symhony

    no mountain villa

    no osaka tiger and dragon

    i do have a list of mine somewhere here on what the best i found but i cant remember where i posted it 

    if you want my grade on the bourbon arc ill go with D

     

    it seems the rest of the world contradicts these lists taken by the japanese fans

    i personally and a lot of others disagreed with the top 100 anime that came out a while back

     

    thanks for reviving the forums a bit

     

     

     

×
  • Create New...