Jump to content
DCW Forum

Recommended Posts

Posted

In my opinion it could've been better. Shifting POV is perfectly fine, but I prefer it remain from a third person perspective when doing it, makes it easier to understand. I wouldn't have minded extra details as well. It seemed to leap into the story a little too quickly with the AiCon stuff, it seemed that we're talking about the antidote and Ai's feelings, and we suddenly discover Shinichi has feelings for Ai...I prefer AiCon stories where Conan gradually realizes that he is in love with Ai, much more realistic.

Now, if Gosho Aoyama had hinted that Conan had obvious feelings for Ai that went beyond friendship, it might make sense, but since this has not been shown to such an extent that can be said that Conan truly likes Ai over Ran, this fanfic seemed a little rushed.

In Chapter 2, Shinichi felt extremely OOC over Shiho's clothing. Ok, so she looks beautiful. That doesn't mean Shinichi goes and says, "You're going to wear that from now on." Way too commanding, making me feel extremely disappointed in him and dislike him for that.

I haven't gotten much farther, and since I'm not supposed to be critiquing the fic here, I shall leave it at that. Though I really wish that the author would choose whether or not to use honorifics...the switching back and forth does irk me a little...

Either way, it isn't the best work I've read. Perhaps when I'm through I'll review the story and say a little about it.

Posted

Do you write fic? I'm too lazy to write and I don't have time so I just read

Yup, I do. Writing is what I want to do. <3 I used to be a definite ShinRan (Don't kill me! D: ) but now I'm just a writer who writes a variety of pairings, not including yaoi and yuri.

Posted

Yup, I do. Writing is what I want to do. <3 I used to be a definite ShinRan (Don't kill me! D: ) but now I'm just a writer who writes a variety of pairings, not including yaoi and yuri.

Writing a Fanfic is a possibility of the original series or Writer's desire. No one will kill ya :cool: "Rest in peace"

Posted

Writing a Fanfic is a possibility of the original series or Writer's desire. No one will kill ya :cool: "Rest in peace"

who said i won't?

well if anybody wants to write about shinran i will hate him but i won't stop him or her it's his or her desire as u say

but that doesn't change the fact that i hate shinran

Posted

Writing a Fanfic is a possibility of the original series or Writer's desire. No one will kill ya :cool: "Rest in peace"

who said i won't?

well if anybody wants to write about shinran i will hate him but i won't stop him or her it's his or her desire as u say

but that doesn't change the fact that i hate shinran

Posted

who said i won't?

well if anybody wants to write about shinran i will hate him but i won't stop him or her it's his or her desire as u say

but that doesn't change the fact that i hate shinran

who said i won't?

well if anybody wants to write about shinran i will hate him but i won't stop him or her it's his or her desire as u say

but that doesn't change the fact that i hate shinran

:o Accidental double post!

Personally, I think that everyone is entitled to their opinion. I won't hate anyone for writing something I don't support, it's not truly showing respect and I find if you do feel that way, you'd have 1) a lot of people to hate; and 2) be a little close-minded. Then again, that's just me, seeing as I can't exactly hold a grudge. :x

Posted

:o Accidental double post!

Personally, I think that everyone is entitled to their opinion. I won't hate anyone for writing something I don't support, it's not truly showing respect and if I find if you do feel that way, you'd have 1) a lot of people to hate; and 2) be a little close-minded. Then again, that's just me, seeing as I can't exactly hold a grudge. :x

well u are right

oops i posted the previous reply two times

Posted

who said i won't?

well if anybody wants to write about shinran i will hate him but i won't stop him or her it's his or her desire as u say

but that doesn't change the fact that i hate shinran

you must Hate Gosho Aoyama a LOT

  • 3 weeks later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...