Jump to content
DCW Forum

Leaderboard

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 05/07/17 in all areas

  1. Kuroda was talking before that as well though and we can't actually tell when she started to stare at him like that, which means that we were technically both wrong. And yet she did comprehend it during the case. What?! Hahaha, Gin is willing to blow up an entire train and an entire train station just to kill one person among them (and that's not even the first time he intends to blow up an entire train), Gin directly murders persons in cold blood (Pisco, Akemi), Gin orders the death of Kogoro and Conan on the mere chance that Kogoro might be related to Sherry, Vermouth killed Jodie's parents in cold blood and burned down their house, intending to burn the 8 year old Jodie as well and more, and now Rumi is supposed to be the more dangerous person than these two alone combined, because she passively allows murder to occur and risks the life of one hostage? Sorry, but that's ridiculous. On the rest: I disagree and I continue to find your logic baffling and unreasonable by quite a wide margin, but it's clear that this is going nowhere. I made my points and I stand by them and so do you, and that's fine.
    1 point
  2. Why would that be the last test? You can test a person multiple times. And why do you think that Conan passed the test in her introduction test? She had to give him two hints, maybe she considered that too much and wanted a second test. Oh come on, Rumi witnessed the conversation, gave a sinister smile and then had one of her "accidents" again that would conveniently give Conan a reason to visit her apartment. She also hastily bought the cups, plates and food only after she heard the conversation, even coming late to school for that. You want it spelt out directly in her thoughts? I know that you really desperately want to push Post hoc fallacies onto everybody because you were off-mark with your deductions in the Kendo Tournament case, but please stop throwing that around everytime you disagree with something. Oh no, no, that's not what you said. You asked: " Is it probable for Sera to disguise as someone else and then approach Conan for his help during Koji case?" - Is it probable? No. Is it impossible? No, but again, that's not what you said.
    1 point
  3. No, since Sera and Mary don't have disguise capabilities as far as we know. Is it? Where I come from, using "Hello, my name is X, I am X years old and I'm working as an X" is a common way to introduce yourself to a larger group. Kobayashi told her? Surely they had a meeting beforehand, preparing the upcoming lessons and doing smalltalk. How do you pretend to be an elementary school teacher all day, six days a week, while you also are attending high school at the same time and have a social life there? Also, would Masumi take the risk to let Ayumi die? Would Masumi just accept the death of Banno's girlfriend, just to test Conan, which she doesn't need to do anymore, since she already knows he is smart? Seems pretty impossible to me.
    1 point
×
×
  • Create New...